Potbelly Menu USA – Updated Prices 2026
Potbelly runs from about $1.00 for small add-ons up to $39.90 for catering trays, with Original sandwiches typically $7-$9, Big size adding $2-$3, and a full meal landing between $8 and $15. Below is the full menu across every category, how the app-exclusive Underground Menu works and what’s genuinely on it, and why the sandwich that built the brand is still the one to order first.
How we built this page: prices below are estimated national averages compiled by cross-checking multiple public menu-price trackers as of August 2026, not a single unverified source. Potbelly prices vary by location based on local taxes, operating costs, and regional promotions. Always confirm at your local shop or in the app before ordering.
Jump to: Sandwiches | The Underground Menu | Soups & Mac | Allergens | FAQ
About Potbelly
Potbelly started in 1977 inside a Chicago antique store — the owners sold sandwiches alongside the antiques, and the sandwiches won. Entrepreneur Bryant Keil bought the original store in 1996 and expanded it into a national chain, and Potbelly Corporation is now publicly traded with hundreds of shops.
The defining feature is the toasting: every sandwich goes through a conveyor-style oven that melts the cheese and gives the bread a crisp exterior with a soft interior. Some locations still feature live music, a holdover from the original shop’s character. Sandwiches come in three sizes — Skinny, Original, and Big — and the menu spans sandwiches, soups, salads, mac & cheese, hand-dipped shakes, and fresh-baked cookies.
See Also: Tim Hortons Menu
Signature Sandwiches
| Item | Estimated Price (Original) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| A Wreck® | $7.99-$9.49 | Salami, roast beef, turkey, ham and Swiss — the sandwich that built the brand. Order it on a toasted white Italian sub roll with banana peppers |
| Italian | $7.99-$9.49 | |
| Turkey Breast | $7.49-$8.99 | |
| Mama’s Meatball | $7.99-$9.49 | The base for several Underground builds |
| Chicken Club | $8.49-$9.99 | |
| Grilled Chicken & Cheddar | $8.49-$9.99 | All-natural grilled chicken with Mexican-style street corn on some builds |
| Roast Beef | $8.49-$9.99 | |
| Tuna Salad | $7.49-$8.99 | |
| Veggie Melt | $6.99-$8.49 | Vegetarian |
| Pizza Melt | $7.99-$9.49 | Part of the meatball lineup |
| Wrecking Ball | $8.49-$9.99 | |
| Fireball | $8.49-$9.99 | |
| Sicilian | $8.49-$9.99 | Italian with meatballs, mushrooms, marinara, provolone, hot peppers |
Sizing: Skinny is the lighter option, Original runs $7-$9, and Big adds roughly $2-$3 for a larger portion.
The Underground Menu (App Exclusive)
This is Potbelly’s genuine secret menu — a rotating, app-exclusive selection unlocked through Potbelly Perks. It has, in the company’s own words, its own cult following. Current and recurring items:
| Underground Item | What’s In It |
|---|---|
| The Barnyard | A Wreck loaded with crispy bacon and savory meatballs — added permanently to the Underground Menu in March 2025, timed to National Meatball Day |
| Lucky 7 | Ham, turkey breast, Angus roast beef, salami, pepperoni, capicola and mortadella with provolone — essentially A Wreck and an Italian combined. Widely rated the best of the Underground builds for flavor balance |
| The Clubby | Turkey, ham, bacon and ranch dressing |
| Chicken Cordon Bleu | All-natural grilled chicken, hickory smoked ham, melted Swiss and deli mustard on signature bread |
| Cheeseburger | Meatballs and cheddar toasted, then topped with lettuce, tomato, pickles, mustard and mayo — genuinely tastes close to a cheeseburger |
| Black and Bleu | Roast beef, bleu cheese, lettuce and tomato |
How to order it: Download the app and join Potbelly Perks to see the current Underground lineup. In-store, either name the item directly (“Fireball”) or describe the build — staff will usually customize it. One genuine quirk worth knowing: the app doesn’t let you add meatballs as an extra topping, so meatball-based Underground builds like the Cheeseburger have to be ordered in person.
Soups, Mac & Chili
| Item | Estimated Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Soup (cup) | $4.49-$5.99 | Prices listed are for the cup only |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup | $4.49-$5.99 | |
| Chicken Noodle Soup | $4.49-$5.99 | |
| Mac & Cheese | $5.49-$7.49 | |
| Chili | $4.99-$6.49 |
Salads
| Item | Estimated Price |
|---|---|
| Chicken Salad Salad | $9.49-$11.49 |
| Farmhouse Salad | $9.49-$11.49 |
| Powerhouse Salad | $9.99-$11.99 |
Pick Your Pair & Combos
| Item | Estimated Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Pick Your Pair (½ sandwich + soup or salad) | $9.99-$12.49 | The math gets meaningfully friendlier here for groups and families |
| Sandwich Combo (chips + drink) | +$3.00-$4.50 |
Kids’ Favorites
| Item | Estimated Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Kids Sandwich Meal | $6.49-$8.49 | Smaller toasty sandwiches — Turkey & Swiss, Ham & Swiss, or Grilled Cheese — served with a drink and a cookie or chips |
Shakes, Cookies & Desserts
| Item | Estimated Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Hand-Dipped Shake | $5.49-$7.49 | |
| Cookie Collision Shake | $5.99-$7.99 | Blended with OREO and butter cookies, topped with more OREO — can be made with low-fat frozen yogurt if you ask for it as a smoothie |
| Sugar Cookie | $2.29-$3.29 | A genuine fan favorite — pair it with A Wreck |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.29-$3.29 | |
| Dream Bar | $2.99-$3.99 | |
| Dream Bar Sundae | $5.99-$7.49 | Warm Dream Bar topped with ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate syrup and a cherry |
Catering
| Item | Estimated Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Catering Orders | From $50.00 | Bundles priced per person or per tray, covering sandwiches, salads, soups and desserts for offices, parties and group gatherings |
| Catering Tray (large) | Up to $39.90 |
Potbelly’s Specialty & Services
Potbelly’s specialty is the conveyor-oven toast — every sandwich goes through it, which is why the cheese melt and bread texture are consistent in a way cold-sub shops can’t replicate. Beyond the standard menu:
- The Underground Menu: a genuine app-exclusive secret menu with a real cult following, rotating items like the Lucky 7, Clubby and Chicken Cordon Bleu — not a fan-invented list but an official one Potbelly maintains and promotes
- Full customization: bread type, cheese, toppings and sauces are all adjustable, so no two orders have to look the same
- Potbelly Perks: the loyalty program includes double coin days, birthday treats, and periodic BOGO sandwich promotions tied to Underground launches
Allergen Quick-Reference
| Item | Gluten | Dairy | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signature Bread | Yes | No | Wheat-based; gluten-free options available at many locations |
| A Wreck® | Yes (bread) | Yes | Swiss cheese |
| Veggie Melt | Yes (bread) | Yes | Vegetarian; cheese content |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup | Possible | Yes | Cream-based, may contain flour as a thickener |
Potbelly publishes an allergen menu and offers gluten-free, vegetarian and lower-calorie options. This is a general reference only — check the official allergen guide and notify staff of any severe allergy before ordering.
Approximate Nutrition (Protein / Carbs / Fat)
| Item | Calories | Protein | Carbs | Fat |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Wreck® (Original) | ~780 kcal | 42g | 62g | 38g |
| Turkey Breast (Skinny) | ~380 kcal | 24g | 44g | 10g |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup (cup) | ~320 kcal | 10g | 22g | 22g |
Most Popular Orders
| Item | Estimated Price |
|---|---|
| A Wreck® | $7.99-$9.49 |
| Italian | $7.99-$9.49 |
| Mama’s Meatball | $7.99-$9.49 |
| Sugar Cookie | $2.29-$3.29 |
Potbelly vs. Other Fast-Casual Sandwich Chains
| Chain | Comparable Item | Estimated Price |
|---|---|---|
| Potbelly | Original Sandwich | $7.99-$9.49 |
| Jersey Mike’s | Regular Sub | $8.99-$10.99 |
| Jimmy John’s | Regular Sandwich | $8.49-$10.49 |
| Quiznos | Regular (8-inch) Sub | $9.00-$12.00 |
Potbelly comes in at or slightly below the other toasted and deli sub chains on a comparable sandwich, landing in mid-range fast-casual territory — a step above typical fast food without fine-dining pricing. Average item price across the menu sits around $7.62.
Price Quick-Reference
- Cheapest item: small add-ons — from $1.00
- Cheapest sandwich: Veggie Melt or a Skinny size — from around $6.99
- Most expensive item: catering trays — up to $39.90
- Typical full meal: $8-$15 with a side and drink
- Average menu item: $7.62
Deals & Ordering Hacks
- Download the app to unlock the Underground Menu — it’s the only way to see the current rotating lineup, and Perks members get bonus coins on Underground purchases
- Order meatball-based Underground builds in person — the app won’t let you add meatballs as a topping, which blocks the Cheeseburger and similar customizations
- Pick Your Pair makes the math friendlier than ordering a full sandwich plus a separate soup
- Ask for the Cookie Collision Shake with low-fat frozen yogurt if you want it lighter — it’s an off-menu request the kitchen accommodates
- Watch for BOGO sandwich promotions, which Potbelly runs periodically around Underground Menu launches and food holidays
- If you’ve never been: A Wreck on a toasted white Italian sub roll with banana peppers, plus a sugar cookie
Service Options & Dining Details
- Service options: dine-in, takeout, delivery, in-shop scan ordering, catering
- Popular for: toasted sandwiches, office lunch catering, hand-dipped shakes
- Amenities: cozy atmosphere with live music at some locations, Potbelly Perks loyalty program, app-exclusive Underground Menu
Potbelly Hours
Most Potbelly locations are open daily from approximately 10:00-10:30 AM to 8:00-9:00 PM, with variation by location and reduced holiday hours. Check the app or your local shop for exact times.
Nutrition & Dietary Quick Facts
- The Skinny size is a genuine portion reduction, not just a marketing label — it cuts calories meaningfully versus Original
- Gluten-free bread options are available at many locations
- Vegetarian options include the Veggie Melt and several salads
- Potbelly publishes calorie and allergen information across the menu, including the Underground items
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a sandwich at Potbelly?
Original sandwiches run about $7-$9, with Big size adding $2-$3. A full meal with a side and drink lands between $8 and $15.
What is the Potbelly Underground Menu?
An app-exclusive secret menu unlocked through Potbelly Perks, featuring rotating sandwiches like the Barnyard, Lucky 7, Clubby and Chicken Cordon Bleu.
What is the Barnyard sandwich?
A Wreck loaded with crispy bacon and savory meatballs — made a permanent Underground Menu item in March 2025.
Can you order Underground Menu items in store?
Yes — name the item or describe the build and staff will usually customize it. Meatball-based builds actually have to be ordered in person, since the app won’t add meatballs as a topping.
When was Potbelly founded?
1977, inside a Chicago antique store. Bryant Keil bought the original store in 1996 and expanded it nationally.
What is A Wreck at Potbelly?
The signature sandwich — salami, roast beef, turkey, ham and Swiss. Best ordered on a toasted white Italian sub roll with banana peppers.
What sizes do Potbelly sandwiches come in?
Skinny (lighter), Original ($7-$9), and Big (add $2-$3).
Does Potbelly have gluten-free options?
Yes — gluten-free bread is available at many locations, alongside vegetarian and lower-calorie choices.
How much is Potbelly catering?
Orders start at $50, with bundles priced per person or per tray covering sandwiches, salads, soups and desserts.
Is Potbelly expensive?
It sits in mid-range fast-casual territory — a step above typical fast food, with an average item price around $7.62.
What Makes Potbelly Different
Potbelly’s edge is a genuinely maintained secret menu. Where most chains have fan-invented “secret” orders, Potbelly runs the Underground Menu as an official, app-exclusive rotating lineup with its own following — the company added the Barnyard permanently in 2025 and has cycled through the Lucky 7, Clubby and Chicken Cordon Bleu alongside it. Combine that with the conveyor-oven toast on every sandwich and a menu that traces back to a 1977 Chicago antique store, and Potbelly holds a distinct position in a crowded sandwich category.
This page is independently published and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Potbelly Corporation. All prices are estimated national averages compiled from multiple public sources and may not reflect current pricing at your local shop. Last updated: August 2026.
